Designed for a laptop screen. It works on a phone, but it is best seen on a larger one.

A proposal for global decentralised self-governance, on Nostr

A constitution instead of a ruler.

Nostr gave everyone a voice that no single platform controls. Project Granny Bot is research into the other half: trust and governance, built from the same signed events. In its design, communities write their own normative order, members judge their own disputes, and an agent carries out only what they decide. Its first aim is minority protection: a majority alone cannot find an ordinary member in violation, and any group may leave with its rules.

It is designed as an open experiment that any community, anywhere, could join. If it works, communities everywhere would have a reason to govern themselves on Nostr.

The protocol is specified and tested in simulation. The agent is not built yet, and no community uses it.

The research corpus is password-protected for now. Ask us for access.

  • Signed NIP-01 events
  • Sits above NIP-29 groups
  • Kinds 9900–9910, 39100–39101
  • Every release timestamped on Bitcoin

01 · The problem

Nostr took the owner out of the network. Groups still have one.

Under NIP-29, groups are run by admins whose roles carry special powers, and the relay decides which roles may do what. In a dispute, a member can accept the key-holder's decision or leave.

That is the platform problem again, on a smaller scale: an authority just as unaccountable and more fragile. When the person holding the keys loses interest, the community can go with them.

One light holds every thread.

02 · The idea

Normative order without a sovereign.

World society has no address, no legislator and no demos to appeal to. Yet rules are made, followed and enforced across the planet every day. Legal theory has been explaining how for a century.

The textbook answer is the state. The 1933 Montevideo Convention asks for four things, and Max Weber's definition of the state (1919) supplies a fifth: the monopoly of legitimate force within a territory. Set a Nostr community against the list.

A permanent population
Members, each with a key
A defined territory
None, ever
A government
One it writes for itself
Relations with others
Forks now; recognition between communities is planned
A monopoly of force
None, by design

If a normative order needed a state, such a community could have owners but never one of its own.

Medieval merchants trading at the great fairs settled their disputes in courts held at the fair itself, by merchants' own customs, quickly enough for traders who would soon move on. At the Champagne fairs, Milgrom, North and Weingast (1990) argue, judges who kept a record of who had cheated let strangers trade on trust, with exclusion as the sanction and no state behind it.

Gunther Teubner calls the modern lex mercatoria "the most successful example of global law without a state". Its working court is arbitration: panels chosen partly by the parties, whose awards are enforced by the courts of the 172 states party to the 1958 New York Convention. A Granny Bot panel has a similar shape: part of it is chosen by the accused, and part is drawn.

Historians dispute how uniform the medieval law merchant ever was (Kadens, 2012). The mechanism is the part that matters here: a public record of conduct, kept by people the parties trust. Nostr makes that record a stream of signed events that anyone can check.

In 1913 Eugen Ehrlich, teaching in Czernowitz at the edge of the Habsburg empire, saw that the people of Bukovina lived by the rules of their own families, trades and villages more than by the official code. He called it living law, and his book on it is often read as the founding text of the sociology of law.

Teubner's "Global Bukowina" (1997) carried the idea to world society: a new living law, growing out of networks that no state organises. International custom works the same way, binding states as "a general practice accepted as law", with no legislature at all.

An online community is a Bukovina without the empire. Its living law already exists, in norms nobody wrote down. Granny Bot would ask the community to write it down, sign it and run it.

H. L. A. Hart's The Concept of Law (1961) asks what turns a set of rules into a legal system. His answer is three secondary rules: one that says which rules count, one for changing them, and one for deciding when they have been broken. In this design, each one is an event kind.

Recognition
39100 The constitution, its version chain and its lineage. A new version counts only if an amendment trail stands behind it.
Change
9907 Amendment proposals, carried by ballots at thresholds the constitution sets for itself.
Adjudication
9900–9904 Filing, panel draw, deliberation, ballots, and a verdict whose tally anyone can recompute from the ballots.

Elinor Ostrom found that commons which endure, some of them for centuries, share a handful of design principles. Several are written directly into the Village, one of the project's two pilot constitutions.

Collective choice
Members amend their own constitution.
Monitoring
Filings, panel draws, ballots and verdicts are public, signed events.
Graduated sanctions
Six steps, from a private notice to removal.
Cheap conflict resolution
Panels of seven, and a summary track for admitted matters.
Recognition by others
The open question, and the third phase of the plan.

Apart from the state, none of these orders rests on a sovereign. They hold because the parties accept the procedure, others can check the record, and other legal orders recognise the outcome. Nostr can make the record checkable by anyone. Acceptance has to be earned, and whether a community without territory can earn recognition is the question at the heart of this experiment.

Nostr made speech a protocol instead of a platform. Granny Bot asks whether a normative order can be one too.

03 · The constitution · kind 39100

Two layers. Members read one, the agent runs the other.

Every clause carries the prose members ratify and, if it can be enforced, the rule the agent executes. A clause with no rule cannot be enforced at all, so the limit of the agent's power is written inside the document members vote on.

The Village · d: the-village

No sanction without a verdict

No member's voting rights may be suspended, and no member's content may be permanently removed, except by a verdict following a complete case. Every other sanction also requires such a verdict, except a c9 emergency concealment of a specific item pending review. This clause binds Granny Bot as it binds any member.

{
  "trigger": { "event": "sanction_enactment_requested" },
  "guard": {
    "require": "matching_valid_verdict_event_or_active_c9_hide"
  },
  "on_guard_fail": { "action": "reject_enactment" }
}

No silent exile

No member shall be barred from speaking in this community's public spaces except as a sanction enacted following a verdict, or during a c9 emergency concealment of a specific item pending review. Exclusion by informal means is not a sanction this constitution recognises.

{
  "trigger": { "event": "speech_restriction_requested" },
  "guard": {
    "require": "matching_valid_verdict_or_active_c9_hide"
  },
  "on_guard_fail": { "action": "reject_restriction" }
}

Emergency hide

Content may be concealed without waiting for a panel only where it is unlawful to host, constitutes active doxxing, or coordinates an ongoing raid, and only once three members in good standing have flagged it. Granny Bot opens a review case the moment she conceals the item, and the item is restored automatically unless a panel upholds the concealment within seventy-two hours; concealment exercised in bad faith is itself a violation of c5.

{
  "trigger": {
    "event": "emergency_flag",
    "flag_count_min": 3,
    "flagger_role": "member_in_good_standing"
  },
  "action": "hide_content",
  "review": {
    "opened_by": "agent_at_concealment",
    "within_hours": 72,
    "if_not_upheld": "restore"
  }
}

Hiding deletes nothing. A hidden item goes on a public concealment list (kind 39101) that conformant clients honour, and restoring it means taking it off the list. A tool flags any change to one layer that leaves the other untouched, because a rule that changes while its prose stays the same is the most dangerous edit the system allows.

“The member most likely to require this constitution's protection is the one raising an objection the community would rather not hear.” The Village, preamble

04 · Run a case

No violation is found unless the accused's own nominees agree.

A routine panel has seven seats. The accused names three, and four are drawn at random. A violation needs a majority of the seven and the assent of at least two of the three the accused named. Those three do not need to be impartial. They need to tell a made-up complaint from a real one.

1Choose how the panel is formed

The accused names three members they trust and four more are drawn at random. A violation needs a majority of the seven and two of the three named. This is the Village's rule.

2Choose who stands accused

Or click a light in the field:Or tap a light: orange for a dissenter, blue for a member of the majority.

Named by the accusedDrawn at random× convict · ○ acquit

No case yet. Choose who stands accused.

Event logsimulated · unsigned · shapes from spec §5
  1. Events appear here as the case runs. Open any row to read the event.

In the design the draw is seeded so that anyone could re-run it and check the panel; no implementation exists yet. The plan is to seed it from a Bitcoin block mined after the filing, its height fixed in advance, so that the filer cannot choose the panel. Votes here come from the project's simulation model, not from people.

All thirteen event kinds
KindEventSigned by
39100ConstitutionGranny Bot, after a passing amendment vote
39101Concealment listGranny Bot, from an enactment or a lapsed review
9900Case filingAny member
9901Panel drawGranny Bot, deterministically and reproducibly
9902Deliberation statementA panellist
9903BallotA panellist
9904VerdictGranny Bot, as a mechanical tally of the ballots
9905AppealA party, or any member for a vexatious-filing appeal
9906Sanction enactmentGranny Bot, carrying out a verdict
9907Amendment proposalAny member with standing
9908Fork declarationThe forking group
9909Vouch recordThe vouching member
9910Agent log (optional, research use)Granny Bot

Highlighted rows are signed by the agent, which also files c9 review cases and c5 counter-cases. Every judgement is signed by a person. The range sits clear of NIP-29's reserved blocks; an open NIP pull request (#2117) uses 9901 to 9905, a collision to be resolved before either is merged.

05 · What the simulations found

Majority rule convicts the dissenter.

Picture 105 people: 95 broadly agree and 10 do not. One of the ten is accused of something they did not do, on a charge written along the community's dividing line. A panel drawn at random and deciding by majority convicts, through a fair process and a sincere vote. The nomination rule changes that.

Innocent dissenter convicted Real violation missed
Seven at randommajority decides 997 0
Accused names threetwo of the three must agree 4 8
Accused knows nobodynames three strangers 969 3
Per 1,000 cases, as the project's committed code prints them (panel_selection.py, experiments 1 and 2).
§

Simulated, not measured. These figures come from a model, at one setting of it, and your browser recomputes them from the same model. They rest on assumptions nobody has yet tested with people, above all that an ally can tell a made-up complaint from a real one. Where the accused knows nobody to name, the protection is gone; that is the design's most serious known weakness, and the Village answers it with appointed advocates, which restore protection in simulation only if they judge on merit. Testing these assumptions with people is part of the plan below.

06 · Founder decay

Founders' power runs out, on a clock in the founding text.

The Village has five founders and a hundred other members. In ordinary amendment votes a founder's ballot starts at four times the weight of anyone else's and falls to parity after a year. Panel ballots always count once.

0 months
  1. 4×0–3
  2. 3×4–6
  3. 2×7–9
  4. 1.5×10–12
  5. 1×13+
Founder vote weight4×ordinary amendment votes only
Founders' share16.7%of an amendment vote if every member votes

The clock runs in time, not in members admitted, so a founder cannot outlast it by vouching for accounts they control. It is keyed to the lineage, so a fork that resets it is caught by the audit. Turnout matters more than the multiplier: at five per cent turnout, founders at four times weight would hold 81% of an amendment vote in simulation (research paper 07), which is why the Village also requires at least 35 ballots, capping that share at 40%.

07 · Exit · kind 9908

Any group can fork, and take its normative order with it.

A faction that disagrees can leave with the constitution, the case record and the precedents. Its new constitution points back to the old one, and a fork declaration lists every clause that changed and in which layer. A tool checks the declaration against both documents and reports which precedents still apply.

08 · The neighbourhood

Where it would sit in Nostr today.

Granny Bot adds a normative order, not another app. Projects supported by the And Other Stuff collective, and Soapbox's Armada, already cover much of what a self-governing community needs. This is where each would sit in the system.

  • ArmadaDiscord-style communities over NIP-29 groups and Concord: the groups a constitution is written for.
  • DittoCommunity servers with their own relay. A natural place for a community's agent to run.
  • +chorusCommunity groups with built-in ecash payments. The kind of community a constitution is written for.
  • White NoisePrivate, encrypted group chat. Panels need a place to deliberate out of public view.
  • CashuEcash. A filing bond or an appeal deposit could be held and returned by verdict.
  • AgoraFunding for movements under pressure, whose members most need protection for dissent.
  • DivineA creator platform with house rules, the kind a constitution makes the members' own.
  • ShakespeareBuilds Nostr apps from a description: ballots, case views and constitution editors among them.

Named to show where Granny Bot would fit. No partnership or endorsement is claimed, and each logo belongs to its project.

09 · Progress

What exists today.

  • 100,000+words of research

    A white paper, a thesis, research papers, a protocol specification, two adversarial reviews and two pilot constitutions.

  • 37releases, each timestamped on Bitcoin

    Every version's manifest carries an OpenTimestamps proof, so a later rewrite of the record would show.

  • 602tests for the verdict engine

    The specification's tally as a pure function: ballots in, verdict out.

  • 217tests for the genealogy tool

    It audits a constitution, compares forks and reports which precedents survive.

  • 1community NIP

    Constitutional lineage for NIP-29 groups, on NostrHub.

  • 1working Nostr client

    Bubble Hub, published to Nostr as an nsite.

Not built yet: the agent itself, the panel draw, the state derivation the verdict engine depends on, and a way to show that a relay has served every ballot. No community runs on Granny Bot today.

10 · Roadmap

From one community to a normative order between communities.

Each phase starts only if the one before passes its gate. The long aim is communities that recognise each other's verdicts, as states recognise arbitral awards: a working normative order between communities, with Nostr as the common ground.

  1. Phase 1 · months 2 and 3

    Foundations

    • Panel draws from a Bitcoin block hash
    • Constitutions and their forks live on relays
    • A working paper on normative order without a sovereign
    • Safety design for communities under pressure
  2. Gate 1

    The code runs on live relays, and the legal analysis finds no blocking conflict.

  3. Phase 2 · months 4 to 9

    A first community

    • Outside review
    • A community that did not write the design adopts a constitution
    • An experiment tests whether allies judge on evidence
    • A first agent on a NIP-29 relay
  4. Gate 2

    That community governs itself with it, and the experiment does not reject the nomination rule.

  5. Phase 3 · months 10 to 12

    Normative order between communities

    • Communities recognise each other's verdicts
    • Compacts: clauses that several communities each adopt by their own vote
    • Shared rules for members of several communities
    • Each piece proposed as an open Nostr standard

11 · Adoption

People join Nostr one at a time. Communities could arrive whole.

Every group that lasts needs a way to make its rules and settle its disputes; Elinor Ostrom found both in the long-lived commons she studied. With those settled, a group can put its energy into the change it came together to make. Online, billions of people now live part of their lives in groups, nearly all run by an admin answerable to no one, on a platform that can overrule them both.

  • 1.8 billionpeople in Facebook Groups each month
  • 5 or moregroups, for over half of those people
  • 121 millionpeople on Reddit each day
  • 100,000+active Reddit communities

Nothing in wide use gives a group a normative order of its own that it keeps when it leaves, because until now its rules could only live on a platform, and in 2023 Reddit replaced moderators who protested its changes. Nostr has only just made it possible. Members hold their own keys, every rule, ballot and verdict is signed, and a group can move to new relays with its normative order and its record intact.

Each of us belongs to many groups at once: a union, a team, a family chat, a faith community. It takes only one of them to bring a person onto Nostr, and once there they hold the key, the profile and the contacts for all the others, so every arrival is a way in for the next group. That is how this could reach billions: one community at a time, each arriving with its members and each constitution open for the next group to fork. Each group still has to choose to move, and whether they want to is not yet shown; the first ones will tell us.

  1. First

    Start in Armada, Flotilla or +chorus

    Communities on these apps
    Armada's Concord communities are encrypted end to end, Flotilla makes a relay a community, and +chorus gives groups built-in ecash payments. On each, a group still answers to whoever holds its keys.
    Groups that meet in person
    Clubs, associations, co-ops and neighbourhood groups: real people with real interests who already know one another, which is what the nomination rule needs. Germany alone has more than 600,000 registered associations, each with written statutes. Nostr can give them a base their members own.
    Organising and solidarity networks
    Unions, tenant groups and campaigns, in Berlin and beyond. Palestine solidarity networks show why they need a home no platform controls: Human Rights Watch documented over a thousand cases of Meta suppressing peaceful Palestine content in late 2023. Members at real risk wait for our safety work.
  2. Next

    Where people are already leaving

    Discord and Reddit communities
    In 2025 a breach at a Discord support vendor exposed about 70,000 government ID images sent in for age checks. Bring your server, and your rules.
    Open-source projects
    Rust's moderators resigned in 2021 and most of NixOS's in 2025, each in a dispute with the leadership above them. ngit already runs code collaboration over Nostr.
  3. Later

    Where the stakes are highest

    Bitcoin circular economies
    Bitcoin Beach, Bitcoin Ekasi and the towns that followed have shared funds and local disputes. Bonds can be held in Cashu.
    Movements under pressure
    In 2025 Nepal's protest movement chose its candidate for interim prime minister on a Discord server of more than 130,000 members. We would reach such movements through Armada, Agora and +chorus, after our safety work.

How we reach them

  • Inside the apps. A constitution tab in Armada, Flotilla or +chorus, where their makers agree, reaches every community on them.
  • A constitution clinic. A group's existing rules, turned into a constitution for free.
  • Templates to fork. Every fork records its parent, so the spread can be counted.

What we will count

  • Communities governed by a constitution
  • Members they bring, and how many are new to Nostr
  • Members who go on to join a second community
  • Constitutions forked, and cases decided once Gate 2 is passed

No community runs on Granny Bot yet. Until the experiment has tested the nomination rule, we help communities write constitutions; panels decide cases only after Gate 2.

Sources: Facebook Groups, Reddit results, Reddit moderators, Armada, Flotilla, +chorus, ZiviZ, Human Rights Watch, Discord, Rust, NixOS, Nepal. No partnership with any community or project named here is claimed.

12 · Who we are

Solidarity Works! International

Project Granny Bot is run by Solidarity Works! International in Berlin, which works on global solidarity, human rights and the rule of law.

Lead

Nabil Izagaren

Concept, governance design, simulations, the protocol specification and its tools.

Law

Dr Reik Kirchhof

Lawyer and sociology of law scholar. His Grundlegung einer Soziologie der Scharia (Springer VS, 2019) develops a theory of normative order and law beyond the state and its territory.

13 · Get involved

It begins with one community.

  • A community willing to be first. Ready to measure its participation before adopting anything, and to decline if the numbers do not support it.
  • Nostr developers. To take the specification from proposal to running code on relays.
  • Researchers. For the experiment on whether allies can tell a made-up complaint from a real one.
  • Lawyers. For the conflict with the EU right to erasure, and for liability across jurisdictions.
Nostrnpub180psnwj48pe7wv4275t5c87m9uehxzkdvu0v7uazecsp0lhw7jysz0xufc

What the project hopes for, shown without words: imagined communities across the world, each governing itself by a constitution, forking and recognising one another. None exists yet.